Best Pool Water Heaters: Solar, Propane & Natural Gas

Best Pool Heater :  The Best Above Ground Pool Heaters include 3 categories : Best Solar Pool Heaters / Best Solar Panel Pool Heaters, Best Natural Gas Pool Heaters and the Best Propane Pool Heaters. 

Best Solar Pool Heater :  A Solar Panel Pool Heater is the Best Above Ground Pool Heater when you have the room to place an array of Solar Panels. Solar Panel Pool Heaters have garnered excellent pool heater reviews and have hit the mainstream of Pool Water Heaters.

Best Pool Heater : Types

Pool Water Heater : For those of you in a hurry, the Best Above Ground Pool Heaters are showcased in the boxes to the right/below : Best Solar Pool Heaters, Best Above Ground Pool Heaters, Best Pool Heaters, Best Natural Gas Pool Heaters and Best Propane Pool Heaters. 

All these Pool Water Heaters have top ratings and Pool Heater Reviews. For the folks who want to learn more about the different types of pool water heaters, please continue on ahead.

Pool Water Heater

Pool Water Heater Reviews :  You will find a number of reviews from actual customers about their experience with these best Pool Water Heaters, whether a Solar Pool Heater or a Natural Gas Pool Water Heater or a Propane Pool Water Heater.

Best Propane Pool Heaters

In a hurry : Check out 

the top Propane Pool Heaters 



Best Propane Pool Heater

Best Natural Gas Pool Heaters

In a hurry : Check out 

the top Natural Gas Pool Heaters 



Best Pool Heater

Best Pool Heater

Best Solar Panel Pool Heaters

In a hurry : Check out 

the top Solar Panel Pool Heaters 



Best Solar Panel Pool Heater

Best Above Ground Pool Heaters

In a hurry : Check out 

the top Above Ground Pool Heaters 



Best Above Ground Pool Heater

Best Pool Heaters

In a hurry : Check out 

the top Pool Heaters 



Best Pool Heater

Inside a Solar Pool Heater

Solar Panel Pool Heater : All Pool Water Heaters  including the best Solar Pool Heaters warm water by circulating water into a heat exchanger. Solar Panel Pool Heaters are amongst the best pool heaters as they have a limitless source of energy the Sun.

Best Above Ground Pool Heater : Other high efficiency Pool Water Heaters include Propane Pool Heaters and Natural Gas Pool Heaters. Jump straight to the Best Natural Gas Pool Heater section or the Best Propane Pool Heater Section.

Pool Water Heater

Just as the air turns chilly, Come on in, we will get you to matched to your Best pool water heater or your Best spa water heater today ! This post will take you through a range of the best propane pool heaters followed by the best solar pool heaters , the best above ground pool heaters and then the best natural gas pool heaters.

A warm welcome pool or spa is just great! Soaking your body into crystal clear sparkling water at just the right temperature is a luxury you have earned and now you want it.

Pool Water Heater : Best Brands

Lets start out our pool and spa water heater reviews with  propane pool heaters. I have limited the selection to the top brand names like Hayward, Trane, Raypak, Jandy and Pentair Pool Heaters.

These are not only great pool heaters but these above ground or in ground pool heaters have excellent reviews. Don’t forget to go through the customer reviews on Amazon as well.

Best Pool Heaters : Propane Pool Heater

Propane pool heaters warm water by circulating water from the pool into the propane pool pump and then back into the pool without being hooked up to your natural gas line.

Most digital propane pool heaters run automatically based on temperature settings much like your home’s thermostat. So, without further ado, the best pool heaters : propane

Best Propane Pool Heater Hayward H100IDP1

Hayward H100IDP1 H-Series 100,000 BTU Above Ground Pool & Spa Heater, Propane, Low Nox
207 Reviews
$905.93
See on Amazon
Hayward H100IDP1 H-Series 100,000 BTU Above Ground Pool & Spa Heater, Propane, Low Nox

  • Reliable, electronic ignition for automatic operation
  • Induced draft technology ensures optimum heating and all-weather performance
  • Cool-to-the-touch cabinet surface temperature
  • Plug-in 120 volt electric cord for easy installation

Pool Heater Reviews : Hayward H100IDP1

Pool Heater Review : Roy D, Texas : Worked Perfectly just like the Math says,  1btu of energy heats 1 pound of water 1 degree.  This is an 82% efficient 100,000 btu hr unit and it will heat 10,000 gallons of water by 1 degree in an hour. My over the ground pool has about 10,000 gallons and it took 5 hours to heat it by 5 degrees. Night time loss was 1/2 degree running the heater for half hour bought it back up. My setup has  2 100lb propane tanks with a Camco dual stage regulator. Great Product!

Best Propane Pool Heater TRANE TR250LP

Sale
TRANE TR250LP Residential Pool and Spa Heater Low NOx 250,000 BTU Propane Gas
$2,193.57 - $24.87 $2,168.70
See on Amazon
TRANE TR250LP Residential Pool and Spa Heater Low NOx 250,000 BTU Propane Gas

  • Durable cupro nickel heat exchanger
  • Excellent hydraulic efficiency saves energy
  • Low NOx emissions meet all air quality emission standards
  • Easy retrofit installation

Best Propane Pool Heater Raypak 406,000 BTU

Sale
Raypak 406,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Propane Pool Heater
7 Reviews
$3,059.99 - $659.00 $2,400.99
See on Amazon
Raypak 406,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Propane Pool Heater

  • 406,000 BTU propane digital pool and spa heater
  • Microprocessor-controlled thermostat can be set precisely to your liking , set it and forget it
  • Cabinet and the internals are non-corrosive and rust resistant
  • Features PolyTuf powder coating, polymer headers, and an all copper-fin-tube heat exchanger
  • Also features a stainless steel tube sheet, 2 inch CPVC water connections, burner tray and fire tile

Best Propane Pool Heater Pentair 461059

Best Propane Pool Heater Jandy Pro JXI

Jandy Pro JXI Propane LP Pool Heater JXI260P
$2,268.00
See on Amazon
Jandy Pro JXI Propane LP Pool Heater JXI260P

  • SMALL FOOTPRINT: Ultra-compact and versatile: 2' x 2' footprint for small space requirements and maximum installation flexibility.
  • LIGHTWEIGHT DESIGN: Weighs less than 126 pounds unpackaged for easy maneuverability and transport.
  • BEST RETROFIT OPTION: Plumbing flexibility for quick mastertemp and max-e-therm replacement that requires no plumbing adjustments.
  • GAS SOURCE: This model uses propane as a fuel source
  • PLEASE NOTE: This model goes by freight and will require a valid phone number for delivery purposes

Best Propane Pool Heater Sta-Rite SR200LP

Sale
Sta-Rite SR200LP Max-E-Therm Black Propane Gas Pool and Spa Heater, 200-BTU
24 Reviews
$1,999.99 - $160.00 $1,839.99
See on Amazon
Sta-Rite SR200LP Max-E-Therm Black Propane Gas Pool and Spa Heater, 200-BTU

  • Lightweight - Lightest heater in its class
  • Compact Design - Ideal for retro-fit installation
  • Lower operating costs - 84% efficiency rating - rated 1st in its class for highest energy efficiency
  • Rustproof Housing Sleek, matte black enclosure is made of Dura-Glass - an exclusive Sta-Rite material that handles the heat and weathers the elements
  • Custom or Retrofit - Direct-connects to Sta-Rite System:3 Mod Media filter or easily fits other systems

Pool Heater Reviews : Sta-Rite SR200LP

Pool Heater Review : Thomas R, Maryland : Our last experience with a pool heater was great, but it was very difficult to repair. The Sta-Rite works like a charm, heats quickly and has not maintenance issues. We have been using it for 3 summers (no winter use) and this works fine on all speeds So good having a Pool Heater that works. 

Best Pool Heaters : Natural Gas Heaters

Natural Gas pool heaters warm water by circulating water from the pool into the natural gas pool pump and then back into the pool. They are directly linked to your natural gas line.

The natural gas pool heaters are great for early season or late autumn pool usage when you want to extend the swimming season. So, without further ado, the best pool heaters : Natural Gas

Best Natural Gas Pool Heater Hayward H400FDN

Sale
Hayward H400FDN Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Natural Gas, Low Nox
503 Reviews
$2,969.99 - $769.00 $2,200.99
See on Amazon
Hayward H400FDN Universal H-Series 400,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Natural Gas, Low Nox

  • Standard Cupro nickel heat exchanger for superior value and reliability
  • Patented polymer header and bypass valve design for the ultimate in hydraulic efficiency and reliability
  • Hayward Universal design for easy and versatile professional installation
  • Environmentally responsible low NOx emissions to meet or exceed air quality emission standards in all Low NOx regions

Pool Heater Reviews : Hayward H400FDN

Pool Heater Review : Chris D, Illinois : My in ground pool is 30,000 gallons and the 400 unit took 19 hours to heat the water from 45 to 80 degrees. Good practice is to  close the pool at season end with perfect chemical balance. Using a solar bubble cover will save a tonne of heat loss at night.

Best Natural Gas Pool Heater TRANE TR400NA

Sale
TRANE TR400NA Residential Pool and Spa Cupronickel Heater Low NOx 400,000 BTU Natural Gas
5 Reviews
$2,746.33 - $2.65 $2,743.68
See on Amazon
TRANE TR400NA Residential Pool and Spa Cupronickel Heater Low NOx 400,000 BTU Natural Gas

  • Durable cupro nickel heat exchanger
  • Excellent hydraulic efficiency saves energy
  • Low NOx emissions meet all air quality emission standards
  • Easy retrofit installation

Best Natural Gas Pool Heater Jandy Pro Series JXi 400K

Jandy Pro Series JXi 400K BTU Low-NOx Natural Gas Swimming Pool and Spa Heater - JXI400N
4 Reviews
$2,329.77
See on Amazon
Jandy Pro Series JXi 400K BTU Low-NOx Natural Gas Swimming Pool and Spa Heater - JXI400N

  • Features an 83% thermal energy efficiency rating with a low-NOx emission system
  • Lightweight, ultra-compact 2 x 2 foot design is 38% lighter with a 28% smaller footprint
  • 180-degree rotatable top eliminates the need for rotating headers
  • Features copper fin heat exchanger tubes, a single stainless steel burner, blower-driven gas and air mix, and a hot surface igniter
  • Equipped with corrosion-resistant sensors, rugged housing, and a user-friendly digital control interface

Best Natural Gas Pool Heater Hayward H400FDNASME

Sale
Hayward H400FDNASME Universal H-Series Low NOx 400,000 BTU Natural Gas Commercial Pool and Spa Heater
5 Reviews
$3,250.73 - $304.74 $2,945.99
See on Amazon
Hayward H400FDNASME Universal H-Series Low NOx 400,000 BTU Natural Gas Commercial Pool and Spa Heater

  • Standard Cupro nickel heat exchanger for superior value and reliability
  • Polymer and low lead bronze (commercial ASME) header for excellent corrosion resistance
  • Hayward Universal design for easy and versatile professional installation
  • Environmentally responsible low NOx emissions to meet or exceed air quality emission standards in all Low NOx regions

Best Natural Gas Pool Heater Raypak 406,000

Raypak 406,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Natural Gas Pool Heater
4 Reviews
$2,434.49
See on Amazon
Raypak 406,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Natural Gas Pool Heater

  • 406,000 BTU natural gas digital pool and spa heater
  • Microprocessor-controlled thermostat can be set precisely to your liking , set it and forget it
  • Cabinet and the internals are non-corrosive and rust resistant
  • Features PolyTuf powder coating, polymer headers, and an all copper-fin-tube heat exchanger
  • Also features a stainless steel tube sheet, 2 inch CPVC water connections, burner tray and fire tile

Best Pool Heaters : Solar Pool Heaters

Solar pool heaters warm water by circulating water from the pool into a heat exchanger which consists of a series of circulating pipes in a solar array which captures the sun’s energy and heats the water during it circulating path.

Some Solar Pool heaters use a refrigerant as the medium of heat exchange and they have evacuated heat tubes where the pool water circulates and picks up heat from the refrigerant that is super heated by the sun.

Solar Heaters are great for the environment and of course have no running costs. No propane or natural gas or electricity to purchase after installation.

The only caveat is proper sizing, if you don’t have enough solar collectors you wont be able to heat the water to your desired temperature. So, without further ado, the best pool heaters : Solar

Best Solar Pool Heater Smartpool S601P

Sale
Smartpool S601P SunHeater Solar Heating System for In Ground Pool
80 Reviews
$289.00 - $95.01 $193.99
See on Amazon
Smartpool S601P SunHeater Solar Heating System for In Ground Pool

  • Keep your pool warm with a polypropylene heat collector
  • Solar heater features 80 square feet of solar panels
  • Pool accessory is perfect for heating any in-ground swimming pool
  • Panel array measures 4 feet wide x 20 feet long. Raises Pool Water Temperature 6-10°F (4-6°C)
  • Installation kit required (Sold Separately)

Best Solar Pool Heater GAME 4721 SolarPRO

Sale
GAME 4721 SolarPRO Curve Solar Pool Heater for Intex & Bestway Above Ground and in Ground Pools (Includes Intex Adapters)
270 Reviews
$159.99 - $16.70 $143.29
See on Amazon
GAME 4721 SolarPRO Curve Solar Pool Heater for Intex & Bestway Above Ground and in Ground Pools (Includes Intex Adapters)

  • Unique Curved Shape maximizes heat. Heats 5 degrees Fahrenheit in 4 days
  • Durable construction with commercial grade collectors
  • Threaded ports for versatile plumbing options
  • Includes 2 hoses and stainless steel hose clamps
  • For in ground pools (Multiple units may be needed)

Pool Heater Reviews : Game 4721

Pool Heater Review : Rod S, WA :  Great Experience. We have an Intex 18′ pool and this fits just right. In 4 days the pool heated upto 88 and I was worried I have a hot tub on hand! I run the filter all day and the heater keeps us really comfy. I thought we would not use it and the grandkids would use the pool, but now with the nicely heated pool we are often in it enjoying the heat.

Best Solar Pool Heater Garden&Park

Garden&Park Above Ground Pool Solar Heater 48' x 20' 80 Sq Ft Inground
7 Reviews
$319.95
See on Amazon
Garden&Park Above Ground Pool Solar Heater 48" x 20' 80 Sq Ft Inground

  • Increases your pool water temperature up to 10 degrees
  • Most efficient solar panel in the industry - producing over 80,000 BTUs a day
  • Compatible with your existing pool pump - Better than a gas heater - no gas line, no gas bills, no pollution
  • Doubles your swim season with luxuriously warm water.
  • Made in the USA with quality you can count on

Best Solar Pool Heater Blue Wave Solar Blanket

Sale
Blue Wave NS420 12-mil Solar Blanket for Rectangular In-Ground Pools, 16-ft x 32-ft, Blue
809 Reviews
$151.99 - $58.10 $93.89
See on Amazon
Blue Wave NS420 12-mil Solar Blanket for Rectangular In-Ground Pools, 16-ft x 32-ft, Blue

  • UV-RESISTANT - Built for the outdoors, this Rectangular 12-mil Solar Blanket for In-Ground Swimming Pools can withstand exposure to UV radiation and will tolerate even the most intense sunlight.
  • INNOVATIVE HEAT SOURCE - Our technology employs insulating thermal bubbles that trap heat from the sun. These innovative cells retain warmth for effective heat retention even through cool summer nights and cloudy days.
  • EXTENDS THE SEASON - This thick 12-mil blanket uses passive solar heating to increase your swimming pool's temperature up to 15 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • 5-YEAR WARRANTY - Your product comes with a 5-year manufacturer warranty. Your item will arrive damage free with all necessary parts and accessories. If something goes wrong, we'll work tirelessly until you're satisfied with your product.
  • DIMENSIONS - 16-ft W x 32-ft L x 0.5-in H

Best Solar Pool Heater : SmartPool SunHeater

SmartPool SunHeater-Solar Heating System
93 Reviews
$122.10
See on Amazon
SmartPool SunHeater-Solar Heating System

  • Keep your pool warm with a polypropylene heat collector, solar heater features two threaded-elbow adapters
  • Includes, end caps, stainless steel hose clamps, teflon tape, hoses for second collector
  • Trilingual installation/operation manual (english/French/Spanish)
  • Ordering Guide for Round Pools, 12 to 18 feet: One box, 21 to 24 feet: Two boxes, 27 to 28 feet: Three boxes
  • Ordering guide for oval pools, 12 to 24 feet: one box, 15 to 30 or 16 to 25 feet: two boxes, 16 to 32 or 18 to 34 feet: three boxes

Pool Heater Reviews : SmartPool

Pool Heater Review : Gina A : New Jersey :  I use this to heat my 24 ft round above ground pool. I have used a Solar Blanket so far, which works well but he chore of taking it off and putting it back on became a pain. The unit can heat your pool by by 5  to 8 degrees. Purchasing a  diverter valve  allows you to bypass the solar heater at night so that the heated water remains in the pool. And the turn the valve on during the day to use the heater.  You must have bright sun all day long – otherwise this is not going to work. 

Best Solar Pool Heater Jandy Pro JXI

Jandy Pro JXI Propane LP Pool Heater JXI260P
$2,268.00
See on Amazon
Jandy Pro JXI Propane LP Pool Heater JXI260P

  • SMALL FOOTPRINT: Ultra-compact and versatile: 2' x 2' footprint for small space requirements and maximum installation flexibility.
  • LIGHTWEIGHT DESIGN: Weighs less than 126 pounds unpackaged for easy maneuverability and transport.
  • BEST RETROFIT OPTION: Plumbing flexibility for quick mastertemp and max-e-therm replacement that requires no plumbing adjustments.
  • GAS SOURCE: This model uses propane as a fuel source
  • PLEASE NOTE: This model goes by freight and will require a valid phone number for delivery purposes

Above Ground Pool Heaters

Heat Pump based above ground pool heaters are a popular choice for home owners looking for a heating solution for a larger pool that has a small footprint and is environmentally friendly.

A combination solar and electric solution so to say. The Above Ground Pool Heaters use Heat Pump based pool heating to give you the best of both worlds. They use very little electricity and use the heat from the surroundings to help heat your pool water. So, without further ado, the best above ground pool heaters : Heat Pump based Pool Heaters.

Best Above Ground Pool Heater – Heat Pump Hayward HP21404T

Hayward HP21404T HeatPro Titanium 140,000 BTU Heat Pump, Square
51 Reviews
from $3,499.99
See on Amazon
Hayward HP21404T HeatPro Titanium 140,000 BTU Heat Pump, Square

  • Acoustic compressor cover and profiled fan blade ensures quiet operation and efficient performance
  • Ultra-Gold corrosion resistant evaporator fin for extreme durability
  • Titanium heat exchanger designed for maximum heat transfer, efficiency and reliability
  • Durable injection molded UV-resistant body panels that are impervious to rust and deterioration

Pool Heater Reviews : Hayward HP21404T

Pool Heater Review : Joe A, New Jersey : Highly Recommend this Heat Pump. I was worried about using a Heat Pump as temperatures reach 40 at night and I wanted my pool to be at 83.  It took about 28 hours to reach 83 degrees and now I now run them on a 12 hour timer and everything works like clockwork. What was very impressive about this Pool Heater is that the overnight low temperatures did not cause the water temperature to drop . Very Satisfied. 

Best Heat Pump Pool Heater TRANE TR21174T

Sale
TRANE TR21174T Residential Pool Heat Pump Titanium 110,000 BTU AHRI
6 Reviews
- $0.06
See on Amazon
TRANE TR21174T Residential Pool Heat Pump Titanium 110,000 BTU AHRI

  • Most recognized brand for duarbility and relaibility
  • Ultimate quiet performance
  • High performance titanium heat exchanger and coastal corrosion resistant evaporator fin
  • Polymer cabinet for long life will not rust or corrode

Best Above Ground Pool Heater : Heat Pump  Pentair 460930

Sale
Pentair 460930 UltraTemp 70 High Performance Pool Heat Pump, Heat Only, 230 Volt, 60 Hertz, 1 Phase, Almond
3 Reviews
$2,818.99 - $12.43 $2,806.56
See on Amazon
Pentair 460930 UltraTemp 70 High Performance Pool Heat Pump, Heat Only, 230 Volt, 60 Hertz, 1 Phase, Almond

  • Pentair Model: 460930
  • Features user-friendly control panel, LCD display, titanium heat exchanger and state of the art compressors
  • Auto-set controls allows automatic on and off functionality keeping desired water temperature constant
  • Titanium heat exchanger assures corrosion-free performance for extra long life
  • Self-diagnostic software continuously monitors system for peak performance

Best Above Ground Pool Heater : Heat Pump FibroPool FH 055

FibroPool FH 055 Swimming Pool Heat Pump 55K btu/Hr
12 Reviews
$1,549.95
See on Amazon
FibroPool FH 055 Swimming Pool Heat Pump 55K btu/Hr

  • Swimming Pool Heat Pump with 100% titanium heat exchanger
  • Quick connect compression fittings, digital controller and display
  • 20 amps-240 vac circuit, 12 gauge wire, within 50 feet of breaker box
  • 14 x 40 inch footprint, 140 lbs weight
  • Enamel gray case,

This post has explored a broad selection of pool heaters and the choices are all top of line models which should eliminate problems like hot water heater leaking from the heat pumps or the dreaded leaky water heaters.

And if you like some more gift ideas, you might want to check out some other techie gifts from the world’s largest marketplace :

MySolarHome.us is a blog that covers the best in technology and gadgets as well as environmentally sustainable technology offerings. Here are some of the more popular items on the site:

Best Pool Water Heater : end of article

Last update on 2018-10-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Author: Michael Bennet

A Solar energy professional with ten years of marketing and installation experience. Avid and passionate about the adoption of solar and related technologies in all homes. Blogs about all things solar and sustainable at MySolarHome.us.